Skip to content
IOP Science

What to check for when reviewing a revised article

When reviewing a revised manuscript, you are checking that the revisions are satisfactory. You will receive a copy of the revised manuscript as well as the author’s response to the reviewers’ reports.

It is generally not appropriate to request additional changes (not mentioned in your original report) at this stage.

If the authors fail to answer your criticisms, please check the ‘Unsatisfactory Revision’ box on the report form and describe the areas that were not addressed in the revision in your comments.